American Credit Card Habits Undergo Major Shift as Economic Pressures Mount

The Bottom Line: Americans are stepping back from their pandemic-era credit card spending spree, with debit card growth now outpacing credit for the first time in nearly four years as consumers face mounting financial pressures.

The Great Credit Card Cooldown Begins

Consumer spending patterns are dramatically shifting as Americans reduce their reliance on credit cards following years of heavy borrowing during the pandemic period. After a sustained surge that pushed national credit card balances beyond the historic $1 trillion threshold, growth is finally moderating in 2025.

Credit card balances reached $1.209 trillion as of the second quarter of 2025, but for the first time in nearly four years, debit card transaction growth has outpaced credit card growth. Signaling a fundamental shift in how Americans manage their money.

The Numbers Tell the Story

The contrast is striking: in the first six months of 2025, debit card spending rose 6.57% compared to credit card spending growth of 5.65%. This reversal marks the end of an era where credit card spending grew more than seven times faster than debit card spending in 2022.

We haven’t seen this trend like this in nearly four years, with consumers growing increasingly cautious about taking on new debt. This shift is driven by multiple factors, including student loan payments resuming and persistently high credit card interest rates.

Key Statistics:

• Total Credit Card Debt: $1.209 trillion (Q2 2025)
• Average Balance per Cardholder: $7,321 nationally, up 5.8% from $6,921 in 2024
• Delinquency Rates: 7.2% of credit card balances became delinquent by the end of 2024.
• Interest Rates: Average APR reached 24.37% as of January 2025, with commercial bank rates at 21.37% in Q1 2025.

Geographic Debt Divide: Where Americans Owe Most

Credit card debt varies dramatically across the United States, revealing stark regional differences in financial stress. Alaska leads the nation with $8,077 in average credit card debt, while Kansas and Wisconsin have the smallest average balances at $5,329 and $5,370, respectively.

Top 5 States by Credit Card Debt:

1. Alaska – $8,077 average balance
2. District of Columbia – $7,000+ average
3. New Jersey – High debt with dense population
4. Connecticut – Wealthy state with high balances
5. California – Most populous state with elevated debt

Most Concerning Trends by State:

• Georgia saw the fastest debt growth at 20.5%, rising from $6,592 to $7,943
• Twelve other states experienced double-digit increases
• Only 11 states saw credit card balances decrease, led by Louisiana with an 8.4% drop

The Demographics of Debt

Age plays a crucial role in credit card debt patterns. People aged 30-59 carry 130.26% more credit card debt than their older and younger counterparts, reflecting peak earning years combined with major life expenses like mortgages and childcare.

Debt by Age Group:

• 18-35 years: $4,070 average (starter cards with low limits)
• 50s (Generation X): $9,200+ average (highest debt group)
• 75+ years: $3,990 average (fixed income, paid-off major debts)

Real Stories Behind the Statistics

The human impact of this debt crisis is profound.

Nearly two-thirds of credit cardholders with debt (64%) say they have delayed or avoided financial decisions because of their credit card debt. The most common delays include:

• Emergency savings (34%)
• Investing (23%)
• Vehicle purchases (21%)
• Healthcare spending (17%)
• Home purchases (13%)

Economic Pressures Driving the Shift

Financial pressures from all sides are converging to change American spending habits:

Interest Rate Reality Check: Credit card APRs have skyrocketed from 16.28% in 2020 to over 24% in 2025, making debt increasingly expensive. Higher interest rates make carrying a balance significantly more costly.

Student Loan Resumption: With student loan payments resuming after pandemic pauses, household budgets are strained, and delinquencies are surging as overdue loan reporting resumes.

Inflation Impact: Despite moderating inflation, years of higher prices have eroded purchasing power and forced consumers to rely more heavily on credit. Inflation and economic uncertainty continue to strain household budgets, limiting discretionary spending.

Lender Tightening: Card companies are becoming more selective, focusing on well-heeled customers as delinquency rates rise.

Generational Payment Preferences: Younger consumers under 40 are leading the shift toward digital payments and debit cards, with debit cards offering advantages like lower processing fees and faster settlement times that make them increasingly essential for both businesses and consumers.

The Psychological Shift

Money stress affects 43% of Americans’ mental health, and credit card debt is a major contributor. Nearly half of Americans still carry credit card debt, with 60% having carried a balance for at least a year.

Warning Signs:

• 21% of people report being very stressed about their credit card debt
• Nearly 1 in 3 people expect to have more credit card debt by the end of 2025
• More than 2 in 5 Americans are still paying off credit card debt from last summer

Expert Predictions and Recommendations

Financial experts predict this trend will continue as consumers prioritize debt reduction and financial stability. TransUnion’s Charlie Wise notes that after seeing a “meteoric rise in credit-card debt,” consumers are now “reining themselves in” [Source: Wall Street Journal].

Recent analysis from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis shows that delinquency rates have been rising consistently, though the pace of growth has slowed since early 2024.

Looking Ahead: What This Means for the Economy

This shift from credit to debit spending reflects broader economic caution. As Americans become more conservative with borrowing, consumer spending—which drives about 70% of the U.S. economy—may moderate. However, this deleveraging could also create a healthier foundation for long-term economic growth.

The reversal of pandemic-era credit card trends marks a significant milestone in American financial behavior. As households prioritize immediate payment methods over borrowing arrangements, this conservative approach may help prevent the kind of debt-driven financial crises that have plagued past economic cycles.

The takeaway is clear: Americans are learning hard lessons about debt and choosing financial caution over credit convenience. This fundamental shift in payment preferences signals a maturing approach to personal finance that could reshape consumer markets for years to come.

About IntelliPay: We help merchants optimize their payment processing through transparent pricing, expert guidance, and reliable technology solutions. Our team combines deep industry knowledge with personalized service to ensure every client gets the best possible payment processing solution for their business.  Sales@intellipay.com or 855-877-6632