IntelliPay is a PCI DSS Level 1 certified payment processor offering transparent interchange-plus pricing with no hidden fees, serving businesses, government agencies, utilities, and professional services firms nationwide since 2004.
Quick Answer
What's the difference between surcharging, dual pricing, cash discounts, convenience fees, and service fees?
There are five ways to pass card costs on in 2026, and they aren't interchangeable. A surcharge adds a fee on top of the price when someone pays with a credit card. It's capped at your cost or 3 percent, whichever is lower, and it never touches debit. Dual pricing posts two prices side by side, a card price and a cash or ACH price, so the customer sees both before choosing. A cash discount program posts one price, the card price, and takes a discount off at checkout for cash.
A convenience fee is a flat fee for paying through an extra channel, like an online portal. A service fee is built for government, higher education, and utilities, and it can apply to debit. Surcharging is banned in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, and Puerto Rico. Dual pricing and cash discounting work in all 50 states when they're set up right. Puerto Rico is the exception.
Updated October 2026
People use "surcharge," "dual pricing," "cash discount," and "convenience fee" like they all mean the same thing. They don't. Mixing them up is how merchants end up running a program they don't fully understand. Sometimes that just confuses customers. Sometimes it gets you fined.
I've spent more than 15 years in banking and payments, and the question I get most hasn't changed: can we stop eating the card fees? Usually, yes. The trick is picking the model that fits what kind of organization you are, where you operate, and how your customers pay.
Plenty of businesses have already made the move. In J.D. Power's 2025 Merchant Services Satisfaction Study, 34 percent of small businesses said they add a surcharge to credit card payments. The same research found that 41 percent of credit card users had skipped paying by card because of a surcharge. Passing costs on works. How you do it is what customers remember.
The Five Models: What Each One Actually Is
Each of these comes with its own card network rules, applies to different card types, and carries different legal risk depending on your state. Here's what each one really is.
Surcharging
A surcharge is a fee added on top of your price when someone pays with a credit card. It's tied to how they pay, not where they pay. U.S. merchants got the right to surcharge Mastercard credit cards on January 27, 2013, as part of the settlement of the merchant class lawsuit.
The rules are the same in every state:
Credit cards only. Visa's surcharging requirements say you can't surcharge debit or prepaid cards. That includes a debit card someone runs as credit. So card-type detection has to happen in your terminal or gateway, not at the counter.
Never more than your cost. Your surcharge can't be higher than what it costs you to accept the card. Even if your cost is higher than 3 percent, Visa still caps you at 3 percent. Mastercard's cap is 4 percent, but since almost everyone takes both brands, 3 percent is the real ceiling.
One rate per brand is fine. You can charge one percentage on all Visa credit cards, as long as it doesn't go over your average effective rate for Visa. You can also set rates card product by card product. Most of our merchants go with one rate because it's easier to post and easier to explain.
30 days' notice. Visa wants notice to your acquirer 30 days before you start. Mastercard wants notice to both Mastercard and your acquirer.
Tell customers everywhere. Post it at the entrance and at the register, show it before checkout online, and put the surcharge on its own line on the receipt. If you're not sure you've covered everything, IntelliPay's post on the six mistakes that still get merchants fined is worth ten minutes.
Worked Example: What's the Most You Can Surcharge?
Say your statements show an average effective rate of 2.65 percent on Visa credit over the last 12 months. That's your ceiling. On a $250 invoice, the most you can surcharge is $6.63. Move that same business to Oklahoma and the 2 percent state cap wins, so the most you can charge is $5.00. Colorado works differently. You pick one method, either 2 percent of the transaction or the merchant discount fee you actually pay, and post the notice the statute requires for that method. Bumping it to 3 percent because "that's the cap" puts you over your actual cost, and that's a violation.
Dual Pricing
Dual pricing puts two prices in front of the customer before they pay: one for card and one for cash or ACH. Nothing gets added at checkout and nothing gets taken off. The customer sees both numbers and picks.
With IntelliPay's Consumer Choice dual pricing program, customers see a "Total Price with Card" and a "Total Price with Cash/ACH" before they click Pay Now. As I covered in our 2026 surcharge and interchange law update, dual pricing doesn't need a discount to justify it. Both prices are out in the open from the start.
Customers tend to like it better than a surcharge because it feels like a choice instead of a penalty. The Dual Pricing FAQs cover signage, setup, and how to explain it to customers.
Cash Discounting
A cash discount program posts one price, the card price, and knocks a discount off at checkout when someone pays cash. The practical difference from dual pricing is when the second number shows up. With dual pricing, the customer sees it up front. With a cash discount, they see it at the register.
The legal footing comes from the Durbin Amendment, which lets merchants offer a discount for paying with cash, check, or other non-card methods. The key word is discount. It has to come off the regular posted price. If you post the lower price and add something at the register for cards, that's a surcharge, no matter what your terminal calls it.
Here's the math customers see. Post $103.00 as your price, and a cash customer pays $100.00. That's $3.00 off, or 2.91 percent, not 3 percent. Your signage has to make the discount clear wherever prices appear, not just at the register. IntelliPay's post on why surcharges and cash discounts aren't the same goes deeper on this.
Convenience Fees
A convenience fee is about how someone pays, not what they pay with. It covers the cost of an extra payment option, like an online portal, when your normal way of taking payments is the counter or the mail.
Visa is the strictest here. Under the Visa Rules, a convenience fee has to be a flat dollar amount, not a percentage. It has to be disclosed up front, and it only applies to the extra channel. You can't charge one at the counter. You can't charge one if online is the only way you take payments. And the same fee has to apply to every payment type in that channel.
That's a lot of limits. A flat fee almost never matches what cards actually cost you on both a $40 bill and a $4,000 one. For utilities especially, IntelliPay's post on the inconvenient truth about convenience fees explains why a service fee usually works better.
Service Fees
Service fees get overlooked the most, and they matter most to cities, counties, courts, school districts, colleges, and utilities.
Visa's service fee program lets these organizations charge a flat fee or a percentage on card payments. It works at the counter, online, by phone, and on autopay. You don't need a separate no-fee channel to qualify, and it can apply to debit cards.
Visa made two big changes on October 18, 2025. First, utilities classified as MCC 4900 were added to the program. Second, Visa dropped the registration requirement and the Merchant Verification Value, and the fee no longer has to run as a separate transaction. Mastercard calls its version a government convenience fee, but as our Service Fee FAQs explain, it works much the same way.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Surcharging | Dual Pricing | Cash Discount | Convenience Fee | Service Fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What the customer sees | One price, fee added at checkout for credit | Two prices side by side before paying | One card price, discount taken off for cash | Flat fee for the extra channel | Disclosed fee before paying |
| Legal in all 50 states | No. Banned in CT, MA, ME, and PR | Yes | Yes | Yes, within network rules | Yes, for eligible MCCs |
| Debit cards | Never | Card price applies | Card price applies | Same fee for all payment types | Yes |
| Advance notice | 30 days | No | No | No | No, since Oct 2025 |
| Amount | Your cost, max 3% | Set by your posted prices | Set by your posted prices | Flat dollar amount | Flat or percentage |
| Best fit | B2B and retail with little debit | Online checkouts, invoicing, retail | Counter service, restaurants | Adding an online or phone option | Government, utilities, higher ed |
The Legal Map in 2026
Surcharging: Legal in Most States, With Real Asterisks
A state can make the network rules stricter, but it can't loosen them. Here's where things stand as of October 2026. If you sell online across state lines, plan around the strictest state you sell into. For the full rundown, see IntelliPay's 2026 surcharge and interchange fee laws by state.
| State | Status | What to Know |
|---|---|---|
| Connecticut, Massachusetts | Banned | No credit card surcharges. Dual pricing and cash discounts are still allowed. |
| Puerto Rico | Banned, including cash discounts | Law 150 bans surcharges on credit and debit cards. A 2013 amendment removed the law's express cash discount allowance, and the First Circuit upheld the law in 2025. Talk to counsel before using dual pricing or a cash discount here. |
| Maine | Banned | Maine's statute bans surcharges on credit and debit. Discounts are fine, but the card price has to be at least as prominent as the cash price. Government entities are exempt. |
| Colorado | Allowed, 2% or actual fee (your choice) | C.R.S. 5-2-212 lets you choose one method: up to 2 percent of the transaction, or up to the merchant discount fee you actually pay on that transaction. Each method has its own required sign and online notice. The surcharge has to show as a separate line on the receipt, and debit cards and gift card redemptions can't be surcharged. |
| Oklahoma | Allowed since Nov 2025, capped at 2% | SB 677 repealed the old ban on November 1, 2025. The cap is 2 percent or your actual cost, whichever is lower. Visa's older merchant flyer still lists Oklahoma as restricted, so check with your acquirer. |
| New York | Cost cap, strict display | Under General Business Law Section 518, you can't charge more than your cost, and the total credit card price has to be posted wherever prices appear. A sign at the register isn't enough. Fines run up to $500 per violation. |
| New Jersey, Nevada, South Dakota | Cost cap | No surcharge above what it actually costs you to accept the card. |
| Minnesota | State cap of 5% | Minnesota's 5 percent cap doesn't override the 3 percent network cap or your cost. You also need a no-surcharge way to pay and disclosure that fits each sales channel. |
| California | Allowed, with price rules | The old ban was struck down, but SB 478 requires mandatory fees to be built into the advertised price. Whether a card fee counts as mandatory depends on your setup, so get counsel's read. Dual pricing avoids the question. |
| Texas | Disputed | The ban is still on the books. Federal courts have ruled against it, but the Attorney General says it's enforceable. Talk to an attorney before you surcharge. |
Dual Pricing and Cash Discounts: Legal Everywhere, If You Post Prices Right
Both work in all 50 states, including the states that ban surcharging. Puerto Rico is the exception, because a 2013 amendment removed its cash discount allowance. What changes from state to state is how you have to show your prices. Maine wants the card price at least as prominent as the cash price. New York wants the full card price posted wherever prices show up. California wants mandatory fees baked into advertised prices.
The Trap to Avoid
Some terminals post your cash price and then add a "non-cash adjustment" at checkout. That isn't dual pricing or a cash discount. It's a surcharge, and Visa treats it like one. So all the surcharge rules apply: no fee on debit, nothing at all in the ban states, and a cap at your cost. Calling it a technology fee or a processing fee doesn't change that.
The FTC Fee Rule Is Narrower Than You Might Think
The FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees took effect May 12, 2025, but it only covers live-event tickets and short-term lodging. It's not a general surcharge rule. The pricing laws that reach the most businesses right now are state laws, like California's.
For Government and Utility Finance Offices: How the Fee Settles Matters
When Visa made separate service fee transactions optional, it sounded like a technical footnote. If you're a finance director or county treasurer, it's not.
In our government payments eBook, we point to a PwC finding that manual reconciliation eats about 30 percent of a finance or treasury team's time. Most of that goes to matching deposits across systems that don't talk to each other. How your service fee settles decides whether your deposits match your ledger.
If the fee rides inside the payment, someone has to split principal from fee on every single item. Your bank deposit won't match the taxes, utility bills, or tuition you collected.
If the fee settles separately to the processor, your deposit equals what you collected, and the books tie out.
Before you switch programs, ask your processor three things. How does the fee settle? Whose name shows up on the cardholder's statement? Does your deposit report match what actually lands in the bank? At IntelliPay, our Disbursement Report checks the gateway against batch settlement, so our reporting matches your bank account. More on that at IntelliPay government payments.
State law still matters for public agencies, since many states spell out what an agency can charge. Oklahoma's SB 677, for example, limits municipal service fees to specific costs like bank processing and transaction fees. Utilities should also check their PUC tariff. IntelliPay's guide to utility billing regulations by state covers that, and our utilities page explains how to compare a service fee against Visa's flat utility interchange rate.
A Quick Word on the Visa and Mastercard Settlement: It Isn't Approved
You've probably seen headlines about the $38 billion swipe fee settlement. It got preliminary approval on June 9, 2026, and 978 merchants and trade groups filed objections in September. A final hearing is reported for November 16. Until there's final approval, nothing in it changes a single rule in this guide. Build your program on today's rules. I explain why in how to build a surcharge program that survives an audit.
Understanding What You Are Actually Passing Through
Interchange is the fee the card-issuing bank collects. The networks set it, not your processor, and you can't negotiate it. Here are some representative card-present credit rates. For current tables, see Interchange Fees Explained.
| Card Type | Representative Interchange Rate |
|---|---|
| Visa CPS Retail (basic credit) | 1.51% + $0.10 |
| Visa Rewards Signature Preferred | 2.50% + $0.10 |
| Visa Corporate | 2.20% + $0.10 |
| Mastercard Consumer (Merit III Core) | 1.65% + $0.10 |
| Mastercard Corporate | 2.70% + $0.10 |
Your effective rate is what sets your maximum surcharge. It's interchange plus network fees plus your processor's markup. On a flat-rate plan, that markup is often where the real money is. J.D. Power found flat-rate pricing pushes more merchants into surcharging. Before you pass a cost on, make sure it's the right cost. That's what our free statement review is for.
Debit is a different story. Debit interchange for large issuers is capped at 21 cents plus 0.05 percent, plus a 1 cent fraud adjustment. A federal court threw that rule out in 2025 but stayed its ruling during the appeal, so the cap still stands for now.
Which Model Fits Your Organization?
Online checkouts and invoicing. Dual pricing is usually the cleanest. Customers see both totals before they click Pay Now, it works in all 50 states, and there's no network notice.
Counter service and restaurants. A cash discount program keeps one price on the menu or shelf. Just make sure the discount is posted where customers can see it.
B2B, contractors, and professional services. Surcharging large credit invoices is common where it's allowed. Keep ACH and eCheck front and center, because on big tickets it costs a fraction of what cards do.
Cities, counties, courts, and special districts. A service fee program fits almost every time. It works at the counter, online, by phone, and on autopay.
Utilities. Since October 2025, MCC 4900 utilities can choose between Visa's flat utility interchange rate and a service fee. Run both against your bill sizes before you decide.
Colleges and universities. Use a service fee on tuition and fees, and keep a no-fee ACH option so the fee never gets in the way of enrollment.
Before Your First Fee: A Quick Checklist
1. Make sure the model fits your merchant category and every state you sell into.
2. Pull 12 months of statements and figure out your effective rate by card brand.
3. If you're surcharging, give 30 days' notice to your acquirer and to Mastercard.
4. Set up automatic card-type detection so debit and prepaid never get surcharged.
5. Disclose at the door, at the register, at online checkout, and out loud on phone payments.
6. Show any fee on its own line on every receipt.
7. Recheck your effective rate every year. Interchange changes every April and October.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is dual pricing the same thing as a cash discount program?
No. Dual pricing posts two prices side by side, one for card and one for cash or ACH, so the customer sees both before they choose. A cash discount program posts one price, the card price, and takes a discount off at checkout when someone pays cash. Both are legal in all 50 states when they're set up right. Puerto Rico is the exception. They look different to your customers and have different setup rules.
Can I charge the same surcharge percentage on every credit card?
Yes. Visa and Mastercard let you charge one rate on all credit cards of a brand, as long as it doesn't go over your average effective rate for that brand. It also can't go over 3 percent for Visa or any lower state cap. You can set rates card product by card product if you want to, but you don't have to.
Can I surcharge a debit card if it has a Visa or Mastercard logo?
No. Not in any state and not with any processor. That includes a debit card someone runs as credit. Your terminal or gateway has to spot the card type and drop the fee automatically.
What's the difference between a convenience fee and a service fee?
It comes down to how the customer pays and who you are. A convenience fee only applies when someone uses an extra payment channel, like paying online when you normally take payments at the counter, and Visa requires it to be a flat dollar amount. A service fee is only for government agencies, colleges, and utilities. It can be a flat amount or a percentage, it works in every channel, and it can apply to debit cards.
Do I have to notify anyone before I start surcharging?
Yes. Visa requires you to tell your acquirer at least 30 days before your first surcharged sale. Mastercard wants notice to both Mastercard and your acquirer 30 days ahead. Your processor usually handles the paperwork, but confirm it actually got filed.
Has the Visa and Mastercard settlement been approved?
No. It got preliminary approval on June 9, 2026, and nearly 1,000 merchants and trade groups filed objections in September. A final hearing is reported for November 16, 2026. Until there's final approval, nothing in it changes the rules you operate under.
Do I still have to register before charging a Visa service fee?
No. Since October 18, 2025, Visa no longer requires registration or a Merchant Verification Value, and the fee doesn't have to run as a separate transaction anymore. You still need a processor that supports the program and clear disclosure before the customer pays.
Which option are customers least likely to push back on?
Dual pricing and properly disclosed service fees, because the customer sees what they'll pay before they commit. Surcharges that show up at the last step get the most pushback. In J.D. Power's research, 41 percent of credit card users said they had skipped paying by card because of a surcharge.
Is there a way to skip the fee question completely?
For recurring bills like utilities, taxes, tuition, and subscriptions, ACH is the easiest answer. It avoids card interchange altogether, so you can offer customers a no-fee way to pay and still keep your costs low. Here's how ACH payments work.
Not Sure Which Model Fits Your Organization?
IntelliPay will walk you through the right fee model for your business or agency.
We set up dual pricing, cash discount, surcharging, convenience fee, and service fee programs for merchants, municipalities, and utilities, start to finish. No sales pressure. No obligation.
Talk to IntelliPayKey Takeaways
Surcharging, dual pricing, cash discounting, convenience fees, and service fees are five different programs with five different sets of rules. A surcharge is capped at your cost or 3 percent and never applies to debit. Dual pricing shows two prices side by side before the customer pays. A cash discount posts one card price and takes money off for cash. Convenience fees are flat and tied to an extra channel. Service fees are the right fit for government, higher education, and utilities.
Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, and Puerto Rico ban surcharging. Oklahoma caps it at 2 percent, and Colorado allows 2 percent or your actual merchant discount fee. New York, California, and Minnesota add their own price and disclosure rules. The Visa and Mastercard settlement isn't approved, so it doesn't change anything yet.
IntelliPay helps merchants, municipalities, and utilities pick and set up the right fee model, with transparent interchange-plus pricing and no hidden fees.
Suggested Reading
Disclaimer
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Card network rules are published by Visa and Mastercard and are updated periodically. Interchange rates shown are representative and change each April and October. State surcharge, dual pricing, and cash discount laws change and vary by jurisdiction. Merchants and government agencies should confirm current requirements with their acquirer, processor, and legal counsel before implementing any fee program. Published: June 1, 2026. Last updated: October 7, 2026. IntelliPay is a registered ISO/MSP of Citizens Bank, Providence, RI, and Synovus Bank, Columbus, GA.
